Another Templates

Followers

Powered by Blogger.

Recent Comments

Introduction

Recent Posts

Blogger templates

Created by www.csstemplateheaven.com |
Blogger Template by Blogger Template Place

Harry Potter pwned Twilight. Why?

1. It has a plot & sub-plots.(Twilight doesn't)

2. Based on style and writing techniques used in both sets of books; J.K Rowling absolutely shits on SMeyer.

3. In HP little things turn out to be very important! i.e. the locket in OOTP the bug in Hermione’s hair, secret keepers, Snape begging Harry to look at him etc.

4. In Harry Potter (DH) When the love of Hermione's life left her, she carried on searching for the things needed in order to take down the darkest wizard of all time, and help save the wizarding and normal(muggle) world. When the love of Bella's life left her, she curled up in the foetal position for days and jumped off a cliff.

5. Harry Potter teaches us lessons. Sacrifices are important sometimes. Good triumphs over evil. Never give up. Death is just another journey and shouldn't be feared! What does Twilight teach us? Kill yourself if you lose your boyfriend or girlfriend... 

6. Are their any MALE fans of Twilight? I know both male and female fans of HP both of which aren't ashamed to admit that they love the books & movies.Whereas with Twilight fans, I have yet to fin a male one, who's proud to admit that they "love" the 'saga'.

7. Harry Potter was released at a time where reading was dying. Harry Potter has encouraged millions (including myself) to read.( and not just the HP books)

8. Dumbledore. 'Nuff said.

9. Protagonist characters i.e Dobby and Fred die. This just makes the book more realistic. Not every good guy gets out alive in real life. And the fact that JKR has made each character have a history and made them 'deep', means that when something significant happens (the deaths)emotions can really be felt. (side note, I cried when I read Dobby's death)

10. Meyer's books sound like she used a thesaurus to look up every other word (in order to replace them with BIG, impressive sounding words), as a poor attempt to hide her even poorer writing style. 

11. There is more complexity to Snape's character than there is to the whole of the Twilight 'saga'.

12. Twilight has a massive anti-base and there are many, many people who don't like the book. Not so with Harry Potter. There are very few people who hate it. And the HP antis are mainly those saying it's again Christianity and barely have any valid arguments.

13. A lot of "Twi-hards" argue that Harry Potter is not suitable for children. I cease to see how. I'll admit, starting at book 4, they may be a bit hard for children to read and a bit more adult, but compare it with Twilight.....Would you really have your 7 year old read SMeyers sexual fantasies?

14. The characters change with their ages, did you notice that Bella was in school a year or two longer than she was supposed to be? 

15. JKR created a whole WORLD. Complete with history. SMeyer wrote a story, which, when I read it, just seemed like a semi-decent fanfiction type thing.

16. Unnecessary details are added to the Twilight books. Do we really need to know the fabric of the jumper Bella was wearing? No. It's just page filler, unimportant, and simply boring information. All the details in HP (as I've said before) are important. every detail is there for a reason and is explained later on.

17. JKR doesn't repeat herself 500 times, using the same comparison EVERY SINGLE TIME. We get it Edward is hard and cold like granite; you don't need to use that analogy every time his name is mentioned. 

18. The HP characters have flaws. Just like in real life. Not everyone is perfect, that's a fact. Something Smeyer can't seem to grasp is that people have flaws. Harry may be the main character in the books, but he isn't the best at everything is he? He is a rule breaker and has emotional breakdowns. Hermione is extremely intelligent but at the same time, bossy and annoying. Ron walked out on Harry in the last book- that doesn't make him perfect at all. 

19. Characters in HP don't suddenly change species in order to hastily tie up loose ends that the author was to lazy to pull together satisfactorily. i.e. "Oh its ok hes not REALLY a warewolf, hes a shape-shifter! Did I mention that I love Edward and that he's hard and cold like granite?"

20. The flaws in the plan. If Edward's body is unable to change, how the hell did he manage to get Bella pregnant? Harry Potter has no flaws like this- NONE! 

21. Harry Potter signifies love. Voldemort was unable to kill Harry because of his mother's sacrifice and love for him. That makes sense because Voldemort was so evil that he could not take the force of something so good. LOVE is a big factor in the whole Potter series. Seriously, people call Twilight LOVE stories... they think its cute when a dude sneaks in a chick's room to watch her sleep? That is stalking and its creepy, not romantic...

22.  JK Rowling EXPLAINS everything. Why Snape hated Harry but saved his life whenever he was in trouble. Why Ludo Bagman kept helping Harry. Why Draco turned out to be so insecure... It isn't like that in Twilight. Some things are explained and somethings are not. Connect the pieces, please... it makes a story better. 

       23. Twilight has one, if not no strong female roles. Whwreas HP has Hermione, Ginny, Luna, McGonagoll, Mrs Weasley etc

24. Actors in movies. Daniel Radcliffe never played another movie before, in some of the movies he's not even THAT hot, and people still love him. Because he has TALENT!

25. Quidditch vs. Baseball? Hmmm...

26. Bella is a Mary Sue.

27. Stephen King says, and I quote "the real difference [between Rowling and Meyer] is that Jo Rowling is a terrific writer, and Stephenie Meyer can't write worth a darn. She's not very good."

28. How long did Bella and Edward know each other before they "fell in love"? Harry falls in love with Ginny after six years and even then there's the 'denial stage'. 

29. Notice how there are no ugly people in Twilight. Jacob is beautiful, Edward is perfect, all the vampires are gorgeous, all the werewolves are exotically beautiful- get my point? So, it all comes down to looks to SMeyer while JKR makes us love the characters not because of their looks but because of their personalities. 

30. I know there'll still be Twilight fans thinking that Twilight is a better book, but it's not.Like or love Twilight all you want, but you have to admit, it is nothing compared to HP. And for those still not convinced; lets look at figures shall we?New moon sold 5.3 million copies. Chamber of Secrets sold 77 million copies. Eclipse sold 4.5 million copies. Prisoner of Azkaban sold 61 million copies. Breaking Dawn sold 3.7 million copies. Goblet of Fire sold 66 million copies.

 There are literally 1000's of reasons why Harry Potter is superior, but I shan't list any more. I feel like these 30 reasons are adequate enough to make a "Twi-hards" see why HP will forever and always be better than Twilight.

Post a Comment